Skip to main content
  • News
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Search

Natural Resource Governance Institute

  • Topics
    Beneficial ownership
    Economic diversification
    Mandatory payment disclosure
    Revenue sharing
    Civic space
    Energy transition
    Measurement of environmental and social impacts
    Sovereign wealth funds
    Commodity prices
    Global initiatives
    Measurement of governance
    State-owned enterprises
    Contract transparency and monitoring
    Legislation and regulation
    Open data
    Subnational governance
    Coronavirus
    Licensing and negotiation
    Revenue management
    Tax policy and revenue collection
    Corruption
  • Approach
    • Stakeholders
      • Civil society actors
      • Government officials
      • Journalists and media
      • Parliaments and political parties
      • Private sector
    • Natural Resource Charter
    • Regional knowledge hubs
  • Countries
    NRGI Priority Countries
    Colombia
    Guinea
    Myanmar
    Tanzania
    Dem. Rep. of Congo
    Mexico
    Nigeria
    Tunisia
    Ghana
    Mongolia
    Peru
    Uganda
    OTHER COUNTRIES
  • Learning
    • Training
      • Residential training courses
        • Advanced
        • Executive
        • Anglophone Africa
        • Francophone Africa
        • Asia-Pacific
        • Eurasia
        • Latin America
        • Middle East and North Africa
      • Online training courses
        • Massive open online course (MOOC)
        • Interactive course: Petronia
      • Trainers' modules
        • (empty)
    • Primers
    • Glossary
  • Analysis & Tools
    • Publications
    • Tools
    • Economic models
  • About Us
    • What we do
      • 2020-2025 Strategy
      • Country prioritization
    • NRGI impact
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Council
    • Leadership team
    • Experts and staff
    • Careers and opportunities
    • Contact us
    • Financials
    • Grant-making
    • Privacy policy
  • News
  • Events
  • Blog

You are here

  1. Home
  2. Blog

Five Ways to Improve Ukraine’s Draft Extractives Transparency Law

11 April 2018
Author
Nasima Nazrieva
Topics
Beneficial ownership, Contract transparency and monitoring, Corruption, Legislation and regulation
Stakeholders
Civil society actors, Government officials, Journalists and media, Parliaments and political parties, Private sector
Precepts
P2 P3 What are Natural Resource Charter precepts?
Social Sharing

A widely backed draft law on extractives industries transparency passed its first reading in Ukraine’s parliament in March. It is an important milestone in the country’s oil, gas and mining sectors, and, crucially, addresses opaque licensing processes.

After the first passage, a window for submitting suggestions for improvements to the draft law opened. Key recommendations from the Natural Resource Governance Institute were incorporated into the text of the law during a discussion on 2 April in parliament. Subject to final approval in the law’s second reading, for which a date has not yet been set, these changes would considerably strengthen the legislation.

The version of the law that passed its first reading in March aims to set out legal principles for the collection, disclosure and dissemination of data on Ukraine’s extractive industries. It takes some significant steps forward.

A report from Ukraine civil society organization Dixi Group outlined how the current licensing system is complicated, bureacratic, unpredictable and prone to corruption. For example, obtaining necessary documents for putting a new oil and gas field or a mining project into industrial operation takes 42 months. Furthermore, license-holders are under no mandatory timeline to develop such projects.

The March draft law promotes reporting for each license and special permit. It also aims to make it easier to determine tax avoidance and slap offenders with substantial penalties.

In total, more than 70 special permits covering more than 11,000 square kilometers, or 30 percent of all licensed areas, can be classified as “dormant” (i.e., not in active exploration, development nor production). According to Dixi Group, state budget rental income from the extraction of oil and gas condensate in 2017 amounted to UAH 40.8 billion (USD 1.55 billion). If the dormant licenses were active, companies would pay an UAH 12.26 billion in rent to the state budget.

One of the law’s important clauses mandates that the Ministry of Energy publish electronic copies of special permits and information on each contract’s terms regarding subsoil use on its website.

The law would benefit from the following recommendations NRGI has proposed ahead of a second reading. NRGI’s recommendations reinforce the law’s main message—to increase transparency across the extractives decision chain.

  • The law should mandate transparency across the full extractives decision chain and should suggest transparency best practices directly into relevant sector laws, policies and practices. One approach would be for the law to enumerate the general categories of required disclosure and mandate future regulations and/or reforms to sector laws contain detailed reporting requirements for each disclosure area. Regulation development should involve relevant regulators and agencies.
  • The law should focus on more timely and mainstreamed ongoing reporting, rather than multiple standalone annual reports. To facilitate more timely and mainstreamed disclosures, the term “Reporting Period” could, at minimum, be revised to mean “a calendar year or such shorter period as may be established.”
  • Payment disclosures should be disaggregated with respect to projects and joint ventures. Extractive entities should report their share of payments to government arising from joint ventures on a proportionate share basis.
  • The law should require the full-text disclosure of all new permits and agreements along with any amendments or annexes. Given that full-text disclosure is required to understand the nuances of agreed terms, legislators should make it clear that the government should disclose the full text of all permits approved by the government and agreements made between the government and companies, along with annexes and amendments.
  • The law’s reference to reporting the “absence” of beneficial owners—the individuals who ultimately control or profit from a company—should be removed and additional extractives-specific beneficial ownership reporting requirements, including on lower control thresholds and politically exposed persons, should be specified. The law requires disclosure of information on beneficial owners or “on their absence.” Including the option to disclose information on the “absence” of beneficial owners opens the door to a major potential loophole that companies could exploit to avoid disclosing beneficial ownership information.
For NRGI, Dixi Group and other Ukraine stakeholders, this has been a multiyear transparency battle. If designed correctly, the proposed law could enable any Ukrainian to view companies’ reports on the taxes they pay to the national and local budgets, companies’ overall production and the identities of their ultimate beneficial owners. This level of transparency is critical if Ukraine’s extractive industries are to be held accountable.

Nasima Nazrieva is a consultant with the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) in Ukraine.

Related content

Legal and Fiscal Framework of Extractive Industries

Event type: 
Training
Monday, December 5, 2016 - 08:00 to Wednesday, December 7, 2016 - 17:30
Baku, Azerbaijan

Open Government Partnership Global Summit 2016

Event type: 
Conference
Monday, December 5, 2016 - 08:00 to Friday, December 9, 2016 - 17:00
Paris, France

May 2015 Letter from the President

14 May 2015

Ghana’s Election: Seven Extractives Governance Recommendations for the Next Government

1 December 2016
Samuel Bekoe, Mark Evans, Emmanuel Kuyole, Rushaiya Ibrahim-Tanko, Adams Fusheini

Natural Resource Charter Benchmarking Framework: 170 Crucial Questions for Resource-Rich Countries

Robert Pitman, David Manley
17 October 2016

Recent Tweets

  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    🖥️ NRGI and @ETH_NADEL are hosting a webinar this Friday on the role of investors and civil society in the future o… t.co/iXLuQhQrmJ
    3 hours 44 min ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    🇬🇭 As the Ghanaian government is becoming more dependent on extractive production, what is the role of #extractive… t.co/k5ivbXKydj
    5 hours 33 min ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    🎥 What are the governance challenges facing the #mining sector in the #Andean countries in the context of the globa… t.co/mP8xA5Dxjj
    12 hours 20 min ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
Helping people to realize the benefits of their countries’ endowments of oil, gas and minerals.
Follow on Facebook Follow on Twitter Subscribe to Updates
  • Topics
    Beneficial ownership
    Civic space
    Commodity prices
    Contract transparency and monitoring
    Coronavirus
    Corruption
    Economic diversification
    Energy transition
    Global initiatives
    Legislation and regulation
    Licensing and negotiation
    Mandatory payment disclosure
    Measurement of environmental and social impacts
    Measurement of governance
    Open data
    Revenue management
    Revenue sharing
    Sovereign wealth funds
    State-owned enterprises
    Subnational governance
    Tax policy and revenue collection
  • Approach
    • Stakeholders
    • Natural Resource Charter
    • Regional knowledge hubs
  • Priority
    Countries
    • Colombia
    • Dem. Rep. of Congo
    • Ghana
    • Guinea
    • Mexico
    • Mongolia
    • Myanmar
    • Nigeria
    • Peru
    • Tanzania
    • Tunisia
    • Uganda
  • Learning
    • Training
    • Primers
  • Analysis & Tools
    • Publications
    • Tools
    • Economic models
  • About Us
    • What we do
    • NRGI impact
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Council
    • Leadership team
    • Experts and staff
    • Careers and opportunities
    • Contact us
    • Financials
    • Grant-making
    • Privacy policy
  • News
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Search