Skip to main content
  • News
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Search

Natural Resource Governance Institute

  • Topics
    Beneficial ownership
    Economic diversification
    Mandatory payment disclosure
    Revenue sharing
    Civic space
    Energy transition
    Measurement of environmental and social impacts
    Sovereign wealth funds
    Commodity prices
    Global initiatives
    Measurement of governance
    State-owned enterprises
    Contract transparency and monitoring
    Legislation and regulation
    Open data
    Subnational governance
    Coronavirus
    Licensing and negotiation
    Revenue management
    Tax policy and revenue collection
    Corruption
  • Approach
    • Stakeholders
      • Civil society actors
      • Government officials
      • Journalists and media
      • Parliaments and political parties
      • Private sector
    • Natural Resource Charter
    • Regional knowledge hubs
  • Countries
    NRGI Priority Countries
    Colombia
    Guinea
    Myanmar
    Tanzania
    Dem. Rep. of Congo
    Mexico
    Nigeria
    Tunisia
    Ghana
    Mongolia
    Peru
    Uganda
    OTHER COUNTRIES
  • Learning
    • Training
      • Residential training courses
        • Advanced
        • Executive
        • Anglophone Africa
        • Francophone Africa
        • Asia-Pacific
        • Eurasia
        • Latin America
        • Middle East and North Africa
      • Online training courses
        • Massive open online course (MOOC)
        • Interactive course: Petronia
      • Trainers' modules
        • (empty)
    • Primers
    • Glossary
  • Analysis & Tools
    • Publications
    • Tools
    • Economic models
  • About Us
    • What we do
      • 2020-2025 Strategy
      • Country prioritization
    • NRGI impact
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Council
    • Leadership team
    • Experts and staff
    • Careers and opportunities
    • Contact us
    • Financials
    • Grant-making
    • Privacy policy
  • News
  • Events
  • Blog

You are here

  1. Home
  2. Blog

Model Communities: Philippines Stakeholders Flex Mining Negotiation Muscle

24 October 2017
Author
Thomas Lassourd
Countries
Philippines
Social Sharing

Earlier this month I visited Davao, Philippines, to help lead a workshop on using Excel-based fiscal models to forecast potential revenues from mining projects. “Charting the Future” was its punny, ambitious title.

The course highlighted how impactful access to fiscal models and open data can be to those who seek to  analyze extractive projects, and a common feeling emerged that local populations should benefit more from extractive activities.

Organized by Filipino civil society coalition Bantay Kita and the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI), the collaborative session featured officials (from the central and local government), academics, representatives of indigenous groups, and community organizers.

The mining of gold, copper and particularly nickel is an important industry for the Philippines. Much of this mining is informal. Environmental and social impacts on impoverished communities can be severe. So I wasn’t completely surprised that mineral resources taxation generated intense discussion among participants.

From NRGI trainings around the world, I always come back with fascinating participant insights. At Davao, a role-playing exercise designed to empower participants to negotiate better terms as part of contracts with mining companies was a highlight.

The exercise was a mock negotiation between participants, who played a company representative, a central government official, a local government unit official, and a local indigenous community ambassador. (Aiming to broaden perspectives, participants were assigned to roles different from the ones they play in real life.)

Players negotiated the taxation of a copper-gold mining project. (We used the example of Kingking in Mindanao for illustrative purposes.) The negotiation was limited to royalty rates, local business taxes and tax holidays. Each party had its own objectives, but had to come to an agreement. They had a spreadsheet model of Kingking to assess the financial impact of different options.

Below are comparative results of the negotiation outcome for all five negotiating groups. Despite some discrepancies, results show some common trends. Despite some discrepancies, results show some common trends:

  • In all of the groups, indigenous people’s royalties were between 1.5 percent and 3 percent—above the minimum legal rate of 1 percent of gross revenue.
  • Local governments’ share of total government revenue varied between 14 percent and 25 percent. Even the groups that were more generous to the private sector were more willing to cut taxes owed to the central government than to local agencies.
  • The same groups that agreed on higher royalties for indigenous people also agreed on higher local government share, even though the discussions were sometimes heated between their representatives.
  • The mining company (contractor) achieved its target cash flow in net present value terms in all five groups, which suggests that there are reasonable expectations of companies’ business models, even at the local level.

If the outcomes from the mock negotiation are any reflection of more general preferences, we see a clear expectation that local financial benefits of mining should be higher than they are. We can also conclude that when armed with good fiscal models and open sector data, local actors can gain a clearer, more accurate idea of the revenue-generating potential of mining projects taking place on their lands. They can more effectively make a case to increase their share of the benefits.

Companies mining in the Philippines can expect that the next time they negotiate royalty payments with local communities, they’ll be met with laptops, spreadsheets and savvy.
 

Thomas Lassourd is a senior economic analyst and the manager of regional economic analysts with the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI).

Related content

Improving Governance of the Oil, Gas and Mining Sectors Through the Open Government Partnership

Marie Lintzer
5 November 2015

Developing a Regional Framework for Extractive Industries in Southeast Asia

Emanuel Bria, Morentalisa Hutapea
27 January 2014

Free, Prior and Informed Consent: A Moot Point

Carolus Tuah
5 May 2014

Emerging Economies: Transparency and Accountability in the Extractive Industries Working Paper Series

28 November 2012

Philippines Has New Repository of Hydrocarbon and Mining Contracts, Powered by ResourceContracts.org

Alessandra Ordenes, Anders Pedersen, Charles Young
4 December 2015

Recent Tweets

  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    📢 New oil- & gas-producing countries now have an online home. Coordinated by NRGI, @ChathamHouse, @commonwealthsec… t.co/3ECrhYFY4h
    8 hours 40 min ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    🛢️ L'exploitation #minière et #pétrolière peut devenir une source de prospérité pour les populations d’un pays : c’… t.co/uAIJ1pDyxu
    16 hours 56 min ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    In October over 100 individuals from CSOs signed an agenda with 18 policy asks needed to deliver #GenderEquity in t… t.co/dzb4ukh6Fl
    1 day 8 hours ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
  • NRGInstitute
    NRGInstitute
    @NRGInstitute
    Follow @NRGInstitute
    🇬🇭 How can #Ghana’s natural resource challenges be addressed with data? 🖥️ Watch this recorded webinar for a prese… t.co/hYd5LeYi8J
    1 day 16 hours ago.
    Reply Retweet Favorite
Helping people to realize the benefits of their countries’ endowments of oil, gas and minerals.
Follow on Facebook Follow on Twitter Subscribe to Updates
  • Topics
    Beneficial ownership
    Civic space
    Commodity prices
    Contract transparency and monitoring
    Coronavirus
    Corruption
    Economic diversification
    Energy transition
    Global initiatives
    Legislation and regulation
    Licensing and negotiation
    Mandatory payment disclosure
    Measurement of environmental and social impacts
    Measurement of governance
    Open data
    Revenue management
    Revenue sharing
    Sovereign wealth funds
    State-owned enterprises
    Subnational governance
    Tax policy and revenue collection
  • Approach
    • Stakeholders
    • Natural Resource Charter
    • Regional knowledge hubs
  • Priority
    Countries
    • Colombia
    • Dem. Rep. of Congo
    • Ghana
    • Guinea
    • Mexico
    • Mongolia
    • Myanmar
    • Nigeria
    • Peru
    • Tanzania
    • Tunisia
    • Uganda
  • Learning
    • Training
    • Primers
  • Analysis & Tools
    • Publications
    • Tools
    • Economic models
  • About Us
    • What we do
    • NRGI impact
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Council
    • Leadership team
    • Experts and staff
    • Careers and opportunities
    • Contact us
    • Financials
    • Grant-making
    • Privacy policy
  • News
  • Blog
  • Events
  • Search